Hair Putty vs Pomade: Ultimate Men's Hair Styling Guide

Hair putty is a popular hair styling product known for its versatility and matte finish. It’s an excellent choice for those who want to create textured, tousled styles without the shine. Let’s dive into what makes hair putty a must-have in your grooming arsenal, especially when comparing hair putty vs pomade.

Definition and Characteristics

Hair putty is a thick, moldable substance designed to provide a strong yet flexible hold. It allows you to shape and restyle your hair throughout the day without making it look greasy or overly stiff. Think of it as a perfect blend of flexibility and control, making it distinct in the debate of hair putty vs pomade.

Key Ingredients Commonly Found in Hair Putty

Hair putty often contains a mix of natural and synthetic ingredients. Some of the key components include:

• Water: The base for many hair putties, providing moisture and easy application.
• Beeswax: Adds texture and hold without the shine.
• Clay: Enhances the matte finish and provides a gritty texture.
• Silica: Offers volume and thickness to your hair.
• Plant Oils: Such as jojoba or argan oil, which nourish the hair and add a subtle, natural scent.

Benefits of Using Hair Putty

Using hair putty comes with a variety of benefits, making it a go-to product for many hair enthusiasts.

Versatility in Styling

• Flexible Hold: Perfect for creating messy, undone styles or more structured looks.
• Reworkable: You can restyle your hair throughout the day without losing hold.
• Great for Layering: Works well with other products like hairsprays or serums.

Matte Finish

• Natural Look: Provides a non-greasy, natural finish that’s ideal for everyday wear.
• No Shine: Perfect for those who prefer a subtle, understated look.

Ideal for Certain Hair Types and Lengths

• Short to Medium Lengths: Best for short to medium hair where you want to add texture and definition.
• Thicker Hair: Works wonders on thicker hair by adding structure and reducing frizz.

By incorporating hair putty into your styling routine, you can achieve a range of looks with ease and confidence. Whether you're aiming for a casual, tousled appearance or a more defined style, hair putty is a reliable choice that offers flexibility and a natural finish.

When considering hair putty vs pomade, remember that hair putty excels in providing a matte, flexible hold that suits a variety of hair types and styles.

What is Pomade?

Pomade is another beloved hair styling product, perfect for achieving sleek, polished looks with a high shine. If you’re debating hair putty vs pomade, pomade stands out for its ability to deliver a strong hold with a glossy finish. Let’s explore what makes pomade a staple in hair care routines.

Definition and Characteristics

Pomade is a greasy or waxy substance that provides a firm hold and high shine. It’s ideal for creating smooth, structured hairstyles that need to stay in place all day. Unlike hair putty, which gives a matte look, pomade is all about that glossy, slick appearance.

Key Ingredients Commonly Found in Pomade

Pomades can be water-based or oil-based, each offering different benefits. Here are some key ingredients you might find:

• Petroleum Jelly: Common in traditional pomades, providing strong hold and shine.
• Beeswax: Adds structure and helps with shaping the hair.
• Lanolin: Moisturizes the hair and scalp.
• Mineral Oil: Adds a smooth, glossy finish.
• Water: Found in water-based pomades, making them easier to wash out.

Benefits of Using Pomade

Pomade offers unique benefits that make it the go-to choice for certain hairstyles and hair types.

High Shine Finish

• Sleek Look: Perfect for achieving that classic, polished style.
• Glossy Appearance: Ideal for formal events or when you want your hair to stand out.

Strong Hold

• Firm Control: Keeps your hairstyle in place throughout the day.
• Long-Lasting: Great for styles that require staying power, like pompadours or slick backs.

Best for Specific Hairstyles

• Classic Styles: Perfect for pompadours, quiffs, and slicked-back looks.
• Structured Looks: Great for hair that needs to be kept in place with a neat finish.
• Short to Medium Lengths: Works well with shorter hair for precise styling.

By using pomade, you can achieve a variety of sleek, high-shine hairstyles that last all day. Whether you’re aiming for a classic look or need a strong hold for a special occasion, pomade provides the control and gloss you need.

When comparing hair putty vs pomade, remember that pomade excels in offering a shiny, firm hold ideal for more structured styles.

Comparing Hair Putty vs Pomade

Deciding between hair putty vs pomade can be a bit tricky, but understanding the key differences will help you choose the right product for your hair type and styling needs. Let’s break down the main points of comparison.

Hold and Texture

Differences in Hold Strength

• Hair Putty: Offers a flexible, medium hold that allows for reworking throughout the day. Ideal for messy, casual styles.
• Pomade: Provides a strong, firm hold that keeps styles in place all day. Perfect for structured, classic looks.

Comparison of Textures and Application

• Hair Putty: Has a thick, paste-like texture that’s easy to work through hair, providing a matte finish.
• Pomade: Comes in both greasy (oil-based) and creamy (water-based) forms, offering a slick application with a shiny finish.

Finish and Shine

Matte vs. Shiny Finishes

• Hair Putty: Delivers a natural, matte look, making it great for everyday styles and a more relaxed appearance.
• Pomade: Offers a high-shine finish, perfect for polished, formal looks or vintage styles.

Suitability for Different Looks and Occasions

• Hair Putty: Best for casual, tousled styles, ideal for daily wear and informal events.
• Pomade: Suited for sleek, well-groomed styles, ideal for formal occasions and professional settings.

Hair Types and Lengths Suitability

Which Product Works Best for Short, Medium, and Long Hair

• Hair Putty: Works well with short to medium lengths, adding texture and volume without weighing hair down.
• Pomade: Also best for short to medium lengths, especially when a slicked-back or combed style is desired.

Considerations for Thin vs. Thick Hair

• Hair Putty: Great for thick hair as it adds structure and reduces frizz. Can be too heavy for very fine hair.
• Pomade: Suitable for both thin and thick hair. Provides excellent hold for fine hair and controls thick hair effectively.

Ease of Use and Re-Styling

Flexibility and Manageability Throughout the Day

• Hair Putty: Highly reworkable, allowing you to restyle your hair as needed without losing its hold.
• Pomade: Provides a strong hold that lasts all day, but can be less flexible for restyling compared to hair putty.

Ease of Washing Out the Products

• Hair Putty: Typically water-based, making it easy to wash out with regular shampoo.
• Pomade: Water-based pomades are easy to rinse out, while oil-based ones may require a bit more effort and specific shampoos.

Understanding the differences between putty vs pomade will help you decide which product is right for you. If you prefer a flexible, matte look that you can restyle throughout the day, hair putty might be your best bet.

On the other hand, if you’re aiming for a sleek, shiny style with strong hold, pomade could be the perfect choice. Consider your hair type, desired style, and the occasions you’re preparing for to make the best decision.

How to Choose the Right Product for Your Hair

Deciding between hair putty vs pomade can feel overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. Here's a friendly guide to help you choose the best product for your hair type and style goals.

Assessing Your Hair Type and Style Goals

The first step in choosing between hair putty and pomade is understanding your hair type and what style you're aiming to achieve. Here’s how to assess your hair type and goals:

1. Hair Type:

   • Thin or Fine Hair: Needs lightweight products that add volume without weighing hair down.
   • Thick or Coarse Hair: Benefits from strong hold products that tame and control.

2. Style Goals:

   • Casual, Textured Look: Ideal for messy, tousled styles.
   • Sleek, Polished Look: Perfect for structured, classic hairstyles.

Matching Product Features to Your Needs

Next, align the features of hair putty and pomade with your hair type and style goals.

Personal Preferences: Shine vs. Matte, Strong vs. Flexible Hold

Consider what you personally prefer in a hair product:

• Shine vs. Matte:

  • Hair Putty: Matte finish, perfect for a natural look.
  • Pomade: High shine, great for a polished, sleek appearance.

• Strong vs. Flexible Hold:

  • Hair Putty: Medium, flexible hold for restyling throughout the day.
  • Pomade: Strong hold to keep styles in place all day.

Tips for Experimenting with Both Products

If you're still unsure, try experimenting with both products to see what works best for you.

1. Start Small: Purchase travel sizes or sample packs to test both hair putty and pomade.
2. Mix and Match: Don’t be afraid to use both products together. For instance, use pomade for a base hold and finish with hair putty for texture.
3. Ask for Advice: Talk to your barber or hairstylist about what products they recommend for your hair type and style goals.
4. Trial Runs: Use each product on different days to see how they perform throughout your routine.

By understanding your hair type, style goals, and personal preferences, you can make an informed decision between hair putty vs pomade. Remember, it’s all about finding the product that makes you feel confident and suits your everyday needs. 

Tips for Using Hair Putty and Pomade

Whether you’re leaning towards hair putty or pomade, knowing how to apply them correctly will help you achieve the best results. Here’s a friendly guide to get you started.

Step-by-Step Guide to Applying Hair Putty

1. Start with Clean, Damp Hair: Hair putty works best on freshly washed, slightly damp hair.
2. Scoop a Small Amount: Use a dime-sized amount to start. You can always add more if needed.
3. Warm it Up: Rub the putty between your palms to warm it up, making it easier to apply.
4. Apply Evenly: Distribute the putty evenly through your hair, starting from the roots to the tips.
5. Style as Desired: Use your fingers or a comb to create your desired style. For a textured look, use your fingers to tousle your hair.

Step-by-Step Guide to Applying Pomade

1. Start with Clean, Dry or Damp Hair: Pomade can be applied to dry hair for a stronger hold or damp hair for a softer look.
2. Scoop a Small Amount: Start with a small amount (about a pea-sized dollop).
3. Warm it Up: Rub the pomade between your hands until it’s evenly distributed.
4. Apply Evenly: Work the pomade through your hair, focusing on the areas that need the most hold.
5. Style with a Comb: For a sleek, polished look, use a mens hair comb to shape your hair. For more texture, use your fingers.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Using Too Much Product: Start with a small amount and add more if necessary. Too much product can make your hair feel heavy and greasy.
• Not Warming Up the Product: Always warm up the putty or pomade between your hands before applying. This ensures even distribution.
• Applying to Dirty Hair: Clean hair allows the product to work more effectively.
• Ignoring Hair Type: Choose the right product for your hair type. For example, thick hair may need more product, while fine hair needs less.

Styling Tips and Tricks for Different Hair Styles

For Textured, Tousled Styles

• Use Hair Putty: Apply to damp hair and scrunch with your fingers for a natural, messy look.
• Finish with Hairspray: Lightly mist with hairspray to hold the style in place without adding shine.

For Sleek, Polished Looks

• Use Pomade: Apply to dry hair for maximum hold and shine.
• Comb Through: Use a fine-tooth comb to create a sleek, smooth finish.
• Add a Side Part: Create a defined side part for a classic, polished style.

For Volume and Lift

• Use Hair Putty: Apply to the roots and blow-dry your hair while lifting it with your fingers or a round brush.
• Use Pomade Sparingly: Add a small amount to the ends for definition without weighing down the roots.

By following these tips and understanding the proper application techniques, you can make the most out of both hair putty and pomade. Remember to start with a small amount of product and build up as needed to achieve your desired look.

Concluding The Hair Putty vs Pomade Debate

Choosing between hair putty vs pomade can significantly impact your hairstyling routine, and understanding their differences helps you make the best choice for your hair type and style goals. Here’s a quick recap to help you decide:

• Hair Putty:

  • Texture: Thick, paste-like
  • Hold: Medium, flexible
  • Finish: Matte
  • Best For: Casual, textured styles
  • Suitable Hair Types: Short to medium lengths, thick hair

• Pomade:

  • Texture: Greasy or creamy
  • Hold: Strong, firm
  • Finish: High shine
  • Best For: Sleek, polished styles
  • Suitable Hair Types: Short to medium lengths, both thin and thick hair

Key Takeaways

• Assess Your Hair Type: Thin, thick, short, medium—choose accordingly.
• Define Your Style Goals: Casual and textured vs. sleek and polished.
• Match Features to Needs: Consider hold strength, finish (matte vs. shiny), and re-styling flexibility.
• Experiment: Don’t hesitate to try both products and see what works best for you.

By understanding the nuances of hair putty vs pomade, you can achieve a variety of looks, from casual and textured to sleek and formal. Whether you prefer the flexible, matte finish of hair putty or the strong, shiny hold of pomade, there's a perfect product out there for every hair type and style. Experiment, have fun, and enjoy the confidence that comes with a great hairstyle!